SEX DIFFERENCES IN INTIMACY
Sunday, January 30th, 2011A twenty-eight-year-old woman: Whenever I go out with a guy, it seems like all he’s interested in is sex. We sleep together once or twice and suddenly he disappears. I think all the men I know are afraid of a really intimate relationship.
A twenty-five-year-old man: It’s sad to hear women condemning men for being unwilling to get into close, loving relationships. Many of my friends value intimacy highly, although admittedly it’s not easy to find.
The two opinions quoted above about sex differences in intimacy highlight a much-debated topic. Currently, there aren’t any reliable data on whether men and women have different levels or types of motivations for intimacy. Thus, the best we can do is review current research evidence on sex differences in particular aspects of intimate behavior, such as self-disclosure.
,A number of studies show that women seem more adept at self-disclosure than men, and that girls and women disclose more intimate information to their friends than boys or men do. In addition, girls tend to have more intimate friendships than boys do, and women show a higher correlation between friendship and intimate disclosures than men do. Furthermore, women have an easier time building deep, loyal, noncompetitive friendships with other women than men do with other men.
However, the research evidence does not uniformly support the view that there are major sex differences in self-disclosure. Rubin and his co-workers, who conducted a study of 231 dating college couples in 1980, found few differences in the levels of self-disclosure that men and women made to each other. Fifty-seven percent of each sex had made full disclosure of their previous sexual experiences to their current partner, 73 percent of the men and 74 percent of the women had fully disclosed their feelings about their sexual relationship together, and 48 percent of the men and 46 percent of the women had given their partner their honest views on the future of the relationship. Although some differences were found (e.g., women revealed more about their greatest fears, their feelings toward their parents, and their feelings about their closest friends, while men revealed more about the things they were proudest of, the things they liked best about their partners, and their political views), the researchers noted that overall, their sample of college students generally adhered to a norm of “full and equal disclosure.” Other studies have also found that men confide more in their girlfriends than in anyone else and that sex differences in self-disclosure are minimal.
Other research indicates that intimacy is somewhat easier for women than men and/or that intimacy is more rewarding to or ingrained in women. For example, lesbians are more likely to pair off in intimate relationships than gay men. Similarly, sex therapists have noted that fear of intimacy is relatively common in men but less frequent in women. Furthermore, men seem to want “instant intimacy” more often than women, an attitude that indicates a fundamental misperception of how intimacy actually develops.
How can we explain such differences? First, we should realize that the existing research focuses on intimacy in only a limited way, particularly emphasizing verbal self-disclosure. This approach necessarily avoids a more comprehensive view of intimacy as an ongoing experience in which time together, physical contact, and shared activities may outweigh the importance of the verbal exchanges that occur. Thus, it is possible that with more sophisticated studies, male-female intimacy differences would prove to be minor or nonexistent. However, it may be that early differences in the socialization of males and females in our society account for later differences in intimacy skills. Generally, females in our culture have been socialized to show their feelings, while males have been taught to keep their feelings hidden and to show no signs of weakness or fear. (As Kate Millett succinctly put it, “Women express, men repress.”) In addition, females tend to be touched more during infancy and early childhood than males, something that might lead to later sex differences in intimacy. Similarly, the competitive, aggressive behaviors that are generally encouraged in males in our society do not, in turn, encourage intimacy, while the nurturance and sensitivity usually encouraged in females do enhance intimate behavior.
Whatever differences in intimacy preparation exist because of childhood socialization, men are certainly fully capable of intimacy; some of them simply seem to need a while to learn how to find it. In fact, the author Gail Sheehy has noted that men seem to become increasingly concerned with intimacy from age forty on, although many men certainly develop a great deal of intimacy at much earlier ages. Perhaps the real dilemma of the sex-differences-in-intimacy problem has been aptly described by Rubenstein and Shaver in their 1982 book, In Search of Intimacy, who point out that although “men and women need intimacy to the same degree . . . fewer women than men get their needs met, despite women’s expertise, because so many men are intimacy-takers rather than givers.”
*115\342\2*