THE PLACEBO RESPONSE FOR PAIN TREATMENT: ANGINA
Saturday, July 9th, 2011In the 1940s and 50s, before the days of coronary bypass surgery, an operation intended to improve the circulation of blood through the heart was carried out on many thousands of patients with angina. The method was to ligate two arteries below the sternum in the belief that new blood vessels would grow to bypass the block, helping the heart. The rationale for this important operation, which was successful, came to be doubted when the new irrigation of the heart could not be observed. Astonishingly, two groups of surgeons and physicians, one at Harvard and the other at the University of Pennsylvania, obtained ethical permission to carry out a placebo trial. In one group of patients, arteries were exposed and ligated in the approved fashion, while in the other group the arteries were exposed but not blocked. The observing physicians and the volunteer patients did not know who had the true operation and who had the sham. The majority of patients in both groups of patients showed great improvement in the amount of reported pain, in their walking distance, in their consumption of drugs, and in some cases in the shape of their electrocardiogram. This is a rare example of surgery being submitted to a placebo trial, and the improvement of both groups was maintained over six months of observation despite a general belief that placebos have only a brief fading action.*63\219\2*